Simply Comics

Reviews, News, and Views

Search


Powered by

Award Comparison Chart

The comics industry can't get enough awards. For those of you keeping score at home, let's try to compare the Harveys and the Eisners this year:

Award

Harvey Winner

Eisner Winner

Best Writer Alan Moore Brian Michael Bendis
Best Artist Eduardo Risso
Best Penciller/Inker or Penciller/Inker Team Kevin O'Neill
Best Painter/Multimedia Artist (interior art) George Pratt
Best Cartoonist Jeff Smith
Special Award for Humor Evan Dorkin
Best Humor Publication The Amazing Screw-On Head, by Mike Mignola
Special Award for Excellence in Presentation Krazy & Ignatz, by George Herriman
Best Archival Collection/Project Krazy & Ignatz, by George Herriman
Best Domestic Reprint Project Krazy & Ignatz, by George Herriman
Best New Series Rubber Necker, by Nick Bertozzi Fables, by Bill Willingham, Lan Medina, Mark Buckingham, and Steve Leialoha
Best Continuing or Limited Series League of Extraordinary Gentleman, vol. 2, by Alan Moore and Kevin O'Neill
Best Limited Series League of Extraordinary Gentleman, vol. 2, by Alan Moore and Kevin O'Neill
Best Continuing Series Daredevil, by Brian Michael Bendis and Alex Maleev
Best Single Issue or Story League of Extraordinary Gentleman, vol. 2, #1, by Alan Moore and Kevin O'Neill The Stuff of Dreams, by Kim Deitch
Best Graphic Album of Original Work Cartoon History of the Universe, Vol 3, by Larry Gonick One! Hundred! Demons! by Lynda Barry
Best Graphic Album of Previously Published Work 20th Century Eightball, by Daniel Clowes Batman: Black and White, vol. 2, edited by Mark Chiarello and Nick J. Napolitano
Best Anthology Comics Journal Summer Special 2002 SPX 2002
Best Inker Jaime Hernandez
Best Letterer Todd Klein Todd Klein
Best Colorist Dave Stewart Dave Stewart
Best Syndicated Strip Mutts, Patrick McDonnell
Best Biographical/Historical or Journalistic Presentation B. Krigstein, vol. 1, by Greg Sadowski
Best Comics-Related Publication (Periodical or Book) B. Krigstein, vol. 1, by Greg Sadowski
Best Presentation of Foreign Material Lone Wolf and Cub Dr. Jekyll & Mr. Hyde, by Robert Louis Stevenson, adapted by Jerry Kransky and Lorenzo Mattotti
Best New Talent Nick Bertozzi
Talent Deserving of Wider Recognition Jason Shiga
Best Cover Artist Adam Hughes Adam Hughes
Best Title for a Younger Audience Herobear and the Kid, by Mike Kunkel
Best Publication Design Batman: Nine Lives, designed by Amie Brockway-Metcalf
Best Short Story "The Magician and the Snake," by Katie Mignola and Mike Mignola, in Dark Horse Maverick: Happy Endings
Best Serialized Story Fables #1-5: "Legends in Exile," by Bill Willingham, Lan Medina, and Steve Leialoha

The table highlights all of the non Marvel/DC/DarkHorse material. Which brings up some interesting statistics:

Number of non-Marvel/DC/DarkHorse awards given:

Percentage of non-Marvel/DC/DarkHorse awards given:

And for those of you who think of Dark Horse (by which we do just mean Mr. Mignola for these purposes) as being more indie-friendly, here's the straight Marvel/DC numbers.

Number of non-Marvel/DC awards given:

Number of non-Marvel/DC awards given:

Now, I realize it is a little silly to equate mainstream as Marvel/DC, but that is the state of the industry at this time. No matter how you look at it, though, the popular wisdom of the Harveys being less Marvel/DC focused seems to carry out this year, although they do give Krazy and Ignatz 2 separate awards and we were forced to count "Mutts" as an indie award for this analysis.

Posted by babar at August 4, 2003 12:33 AM